 Shea Thomas is a great catch, the only problem is she can t seem to find a guy who is. Convinced that true love is eluding her, she ends a perfectly fine relationship with her boyfriend to pursue greener fields. Applying the rules of baseball to her blind dates, the guys have 3 chances to stay in the game. As the umpire of her own love life, it s up to Shea to make the right call, if and when the right guy steps up to the plate.