 Twenty-something and aimless, Joey Vitello (Vincent Pagano) still lives at home with his colorful Italian-American family when he is reunited with a childhood schoolmate, Mary O Callahan (Marley Shelton). Once mocked as  Scary Mary  this ugly duckling has blossomed into an irresistible beauty. She s returned to the old neighborhood after an intense bout with cancer. When Joey learns her cure was the result of a miracle, friendship turns to romance as she educates him on the crossroads to the Almighty. Joey challenges his family s faith with his new found revelations and chaos ensues as they all search for a miracle of their own.